+- ASK NC (https://ask.nascompares.com)
+-- Forum: Q&A (https://ask.nascompares.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Before you buy Q&A (https://ask.nascompares.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Thread: Advice for First NAS Purchase (/showthread.php?tid=11827)
Advice for First NAS Purchase - Enquiries - 03-18-2025
Hi, I am looking for advice for my first NAS purchase.
I have three use cases for this device: (1) Plex Server (2) Homebridge Host (3) Data Backups. From looking at videos/reviews from your channel and elsewhere, it seems like synology have the best OS and are the most reputable, but their hardware seems weaker compared to the competition.
My plex library has a mix of 1080p and 4k media, and I am unlikely to ever have more than 2 users at the same time, usually just 1. Cost efficiency, reliability, and low power draw are key focuses of mine in my search.
Thanks,
Armaan
RE: Advice for First NAS Purchase - ed - 03-21-2025
For your first NAS purchase, considering your use cases and budget, I'd recommend a few options based on cost efficiency, reliability, and low power consumption.
Synology is indeed known for its great OS (DSM) and excellent software ecosystem, making it ideal for tasks like Plex, Homebridge, and data backups. However, as you mentioned, their hardware may be slightly underwhelming compared to other brands, especially for Plex transcoding, even if you're unlikely to have multiple simultaneous users. That being said, Synology models like the DS923+ could be a solid option, as it balances performance, reliability, and energy efficiency while being fairly future-proof with support for Plex and other apps.
If you're open to alternatives, QNAP offers models with better hardware for the price, especially in terms of CPU power, which can help with 4K media transcoding. For your use case, I would recommend looking into the TS-464 or TS-453D. These models are equipped with Intel Celeron processors, which are more efficient and better for tasks like media streaming and Homebridge hosting.
For your storage requirements (8-16TB), you can start with a pair of 8TB drives (e.g., WD Red or Seagate IronWolf), and expand later as needed. Just be mindful of drive compatibility with the NAS you choose.
Summary Recommendations:
Synology DS923+ – Ideal for reliability, low power usage, and the DSM OS (great for backups and Plex, though limited transcoding capability).
QNAP TS-464 – Stronger hardware with Intel Celeron, good for transcoding and multitasking, and more affordable than Synology options.
Asustor AS5304T – Another alternative with good performance and features, especially for streaming and backup.
Based on your budget and the use cases you've mentioned, I'd recommend leaning toward QNAP or Asustor for a better value/performance ratio if Plex transcoding is a priority for you.